NMSU English Department

English 111 G/H Rhetoric and Composition
Sample E1: A critique of self
 
Syllabus Policies Bibliography Portfolio
Score Sheet Learning Log

E1 | E2 | E3 | E4 | E5


A while back, my Self revolved around trying to be perfect. In high school I didn’t like who I was and so I tried to change any imperfections. I thought I had in order to achieve self acceptance and receive the acceptance of others. I tried hard to be satisfied with who I was and really like who I was as well. I was never really a mean person, but trying to be a perfect person didn’t make me a very nice person either. I tried so hard to be thin like the people that I saw on T.V. because I thought, as ridiculous as this sounds, that it would make me a better person. For me, television was my influence on trying to be a better person.

          In the society that we live in, it is so hard to be happy and satisfied with ourselves, especially our bodies. Whenever anyone sits down to watch their favorite television show, most of the people on the T.V. are thin, have perfect hair, and wear clothes that most people can’t wear because of the snugness of the clothes or just the fact that the clothing shows a lot of skin. In a show like Beverly Hills 90210, the people are so perfect, that it is so hard for the average person to watch the characters on the show and think that they should be that way as well, and they wonder what they could do so they can look like that as well. Young teenagers are especially prone to the influence of what they see on the television and how they perceive themselves. Not too long ago I began analyzing myself and wondering why I didn’t have the sculptured perfectness like the people on T.V.

          Before, when I looked into the mirror and then at the T.V. set, my flaws became very apparent, or at least I made them out to be. When I looked in the mirror I saw myself as fat. Although I know that I’m not or ever was, I couldn’t help to think that I could lose a few pounds and be thinner and look just like the people on the T.V. For the most part I don’t think that the producers of the shows are trying to make children and young teenagers think that everyone should be thin, but they should be aware that especially young teenagers, are influenced by what others look like and what they think they should look like. When they see the characters on the popular T.V. shows like Friends, they pick out the one they wish they could look like. I, like many others, wasn’t immune to the influence brought by the people on T.V. My favorite show is Friends and I watch it every Thursday. As I watch the show, I wish I had a body like Jennifer Aniston as well as her clothes. All her clothes look as though they were made especially to fit her body. I know that in order for me to be fit I have to eat better and exercise more, but that really is a problem for me. I love food, unhealthy food and I lack the motivation to begin an exercise routine. As for the clothes, I’m now in college and I can barely afford the necessities so made-to-fit clothes is hard to come by. There was a time that I got so depressed that my appetite was non-existent and my flaws seemed to disappear, or so I thought.

          My senior year of high school there were so many things that I had to deal with, including wanting to be accepted, my self esteem dropped, as well as pounds. At the time I thought that more people would like me f I were thinner and looked like people on T.V. Just by thinking this way, in a time period of about a month I lost fifteen pounds. I really thought that I’d be happier thinner but instead I scared myself when I stepped onto the scale and saw that I weighed a mere 100 pounds. Although it scared me, it was hard for me to find it in myself to eat a whole meal without grossing out. I was so depressed and uninterested in my health, that I failed to realize that what was happening to me was hurting me. When I looked at my body in the mirror I thought to myself, "Wow, I finally have that flat stomach I wanted." At that point in time I thought I had the washboard stomach of Jennifer Aniston. What I didn’t realize was that my hair was getting dry and brittle and my face looked as though I was the living dead. Fortunately, not too long after looking at my body, and liking what I saw, I looked at my face. The image that looked back at me was so horrifying that I had to look away and I began to cry. I don’t know how I ever allowed myself to deteriorate like that. I knew things had to change before they got any worse. I was fortunate that I was able to see that what I was going through was unhealthy and I was strong enough to make myself better. Some unfortunately, aren’t so luck. With so much emphasis put on being thin, some people can lose all control and it gets harder for them to realize that food is a must in order to live a healthy life.

          Whenever I see anorexics on talk shows they look so grotesque and I wonder why they have such a hard time putting food in their mouth, chewing it, and swallowing it. They know that what they are doing to themselves isn’t normal and yet they can’t find it in themselves to eat. It’s funny how they can admit out loud that they have a problem, but they can’t seem to put in their mentality that they have a problem. I guess that when a person has a low perception of themselves, they’ll go to great measures to try to make themselves happy. If that means losing a few pounds fast they will try a crash diet to try to lose those pounds. If that isn’t enough, it leads to elongating the diet time period and eventually the person no longer wants to eat because of the fear of gaining the weight back. In a way I can relate to that because I feared getting fat if I ate even the smallest portions of food.

          Even after looking in the mirror and deciding that things had to change, I still shivered at the thought of putting on too much weight. I felt that every piece of food that entered my body was going to expand my waistline. If it were not for my caring friends, I think that I would still be like that. With their help I was able to eat a little more each day. After a few days I was able to eat a whole meal and I felt so much better. Soon after I began to eat, my face no longer looked pale and the sunken dark circles under my eyes disappeared. I felt so much healthier and yet I couldn’t help wanting to look like someone else, someone on T.V., someone perfect.

          I realize there is no such thing as perfect. Something that is perfect isn’t human. Real people have cellulite and have bad hair days. The average everyday person has friends that come in all shapes and sizes, unlike the people on Friends, in which everyone looks perfect. Although the show is supposed to be about average people living average lives, the producers failed to acknowledge the fact that not all circles of friends have close to perfect people. I guess what I’m trying to say is that television shows put too much emphasis on what people look like rather on who the person is on the inside. I have gone though the process of trying to be perfect, but failed to be happy. As one of my friends point out to me, I’m happier now the way I am. For the first time in a very long time, I can honestly say that I am very happy with who I am and what I look like. I am perfectly fine with the fact that I gained the fifteen pounds back because now I actually look healthy and feel healthy and I am no longer living a lie. Because of this, I think I’m a much nicer person and people like me and accept me for who I am. I myself can now accept my flaws as a part of me and know that they are what makes me human.

Copyright 1997 Department of English
New Mexico State University
Use only with permission

< Back To Main Index

Related Links

Email the Webmaster with comments or problems.
View a list of previous English Department Webmasters/spinners/developers.