Presented at "Sacred/Natural Sites" Conference, sponsored
by UNESCO,
Paris, September 1998.
INTRODUCTION
The Eastern Khanty
The Khanty, called Ostyak in the Russian ethnographic literature,
are a Finno-Ugric-speaking people numbering approximately 22,000,
and one of the most numerous and widely-dispersed of the 26 indigenous
tribal peoples of Russia. Archaeological evidence indicates that
the Khanty have occupied West Siberia for at least 3,000 years.
The great basin of the Ob'-Irtysh river system, the world's third
largest, drains Western Siberia to the north. A secondary basin
along the Middle Ob' is occupied by the Eastern Khanty. This basin
is drained by major tributaries of the Ob': Lamin, Pim, Trom-Agan,
Agan, Vakh, Yugan, and Salim. The land is subarctic, boreal forest
and bog, with an elevation between 25 and 100 meters above sea
level, characterized by dark conifer-birch forests along the rivers
and streams which drain higher elevation bog swamps, marked by
islands and strips of pine forest (for overviews of Khanty culture,
see Levin and Potapov 1956, Kulemzin 1984, Kulemzin and Lukina
1992, Balzer 1994, Golovnev 1995).
Khanty social organization is based on extended families or patrilineages,
with related lineages grouped into clans (Khanty: cir). Khanty
continue to live in widely scattered extended family settlements
at the center of their traditional family hunting territories.
Many are literate in Russian and some fluently bilingual, but
prefer to speak Khanty. And despite the efforts of the Orthodox
Church, which in some areas has gained converts of varying degrees
of allegiance, and despite the suppression of native religion
under the Soviets, traditional belief and ritual still flourish.
Eastern Khanty economy is primarily subsistence, based on fishing,
hunting and trapping. There are significant differences, however.
In the north, along the lower Ob' (Kazym region) and on the northern
side of the upper Ob' (Lamin, Pim, Trom-Agan Rivers), this pattern
is complemented by reindeer herding. Only in the south, on the
Yugan River, does the pure fishing-hunting economy remain.
Today , West Siberia is the site of one of the world's most extensive
petroleum developments (Wiget and Balalaeva 1997a). Activity began
in the late 1960s with the first discoveries of oil. By the late
1980s all but a few areas (Kazym River, Yugan) had been seized
for production by the Ministry of Energy and the government oil
monopoly, and even today the region virtually supports a collapsing
national economy by providing a cheap domestic petroleum supply
and petrodollars generated from export. However it may be regarded
elsewhere, the collapse of the Soviet Union, it is fair to say,
has been devastating, socially, culturally, economically and ecologically
for the Khanty and their land (Wiget and Balalaeva 1997c; Wiget
and Balalaeva 1998a)). Production was turned over to regional
oil companies, each driven by a sense of quick profits and minimal
regard for the environment or the indigenous Khanty. After 3,000
years of occupancy, there are today virtually no traditional Khanty
family settlements on Vakh, Agan, Salim and Vas-Yugan Rivers though
these were all well-populated areas, rich in terms of traditional
economy, only twenty years ago. Other river systems like Pim and
Trom-Agan are very heavily impacted and the Khanty marginalized.
Only the Khanty families on Lamin and Yugan River systems have
been minimally impacted.
The Khanty Sacred Trust and Land-Use Atlas Projects and
the Proposed Yuganskii Khanty Biosphere Reservehe
We began to work proactively in the region in 1992 on several
projects funded by The MacArthur Foundation. The aim of the SACRED
TRUST Project was to develop the basic data needed to support
any plan for preserving Khanty sacred places and guaranteeing
access to them. The Sacred Trust project was subsequently expanded
and incorporated into The Khanty Traditional Land-Use Atlas Project,
a two-year, international collaborative research project including
colleagues from Urals State University. The Khanty Traditional
Land Use Atlas will identify: traditional and contemporary settlements,
both individual extended family settlements and villages; individual
family hunting territories; places of cultural significance, including
cultic sites, sites with mythical associations, traditional cemeteries;
archaeological sites; other land-use features, such as reindeer
trails, communal hunting lands, fishing, hunting, gathering and
pasturing areas and so on. All data will be compiled into a computerized
database and integrated with a GIS computerized mapping program
(Wiget et al., Ocherki, forthcoming). These projects became both
more focused and more urgent when the leadership of the Yuganskii
Khanty community chose to integrate our work into their plans
to create Yuganskii Khanty Biosphere Reserve, which, according
to the proposal, would link under a co-management agreement the
existing Yuganskii Federal Nature Preserve with the surrounding
territory of traditional living of the Yuganskii Khanty. With
stiff opposition from the oil interests, the Khanty are seeking
international support and working UNESCO recognition for this
proposed biosphere reserve (Wiget and Balalaeva 1997b).
NATURAL SACRED PLACES: THE KHANTY DOMAIN
Different Khanty clans even today claim traditional use rights
to different river systems tributary to the Ob=, in part because
they believe their lineage was founded by divine ancestors who
were also responsible for the creation of the river systems on
which the majority of the clan lives. Most Khanty extended families
live on traditional family hunting territories, protected by family
gods who are considered offspring of the lineage's founding deities.
These lineage deities are the seven sons of the high god, each
a patron of a major tributary of the Ob=. Roughly speaking, the
principal deities are responsible for cosmological-level events,
their first generation offspring for the watersheds of the major
tributaries, and the second-generation offspring for individual
family lands along each watershed. Traditional Khanty thus believe
that sacred power has been historically invested in both the landscape
and the lineage.
A scientific classification of Eastern Khanty sacred places
has not yet been developed. Our more modest task has been to formulate
a working typology, based on our field materials from six years
of extensive ethnographic work, the work of folklore-ethnographic
expeditions to the Kazym region by expeditions from Urals State
University, and a review of the ethnographic literature (Balalaeva
1998, forthcoming). On this basis we can distinguish two main
categories of sacred places: (1) unmodified features of the natural
landscape, and (2) landscape features modified by the addition
of cultural elements. It is this first category of natural sacred
places that concerns us here. Eastern Khanty natural sacred places
can be classified according to their basic elements into two groups,
water features and landforms.
Waterforms
The first category includes a variety of phenomena connected with
water: lakes, swamps, small rivers, ponds, whirlpools, confluences,
rapids, and turns in the river. Khanty believe that they depend
on the spirits living in these places for luck in fishing and
good fortune generally, and try to make the spirits more benificent
by throwing offerings of money or dried bread into the water.
The size and nature of the offering is different in each case,
and the importance of the offering also depends on the reasons
for making the offering.
Large natural objects in this category are lakes, rivers and swamps.
The name of the sacred water reserves can directly indicate the
nature of these places. Such name can include lexemes such as
yimyng, which means sacred, for example, Yimyng Maling, Sacred
Lake, which is situated in Kazym basin not far from the mouth
of the river, Yim Vosh Yuhan. According to the views of Mosyam
Khanty, the waters of this lake have curative powers (Dmitrieva
53). A similar toponym also exists in the basin of Trom-Agan River,
Yiming Tlor, which also means sacred lake. The territory of this
lake was developed in the last decade by regional oil companies
and the lake now has wellsites on it , which insults the religious
feelings of the local population (Sopochin 1995). In the Kazym
River basin, there is the Lake Sasi Tlor, which means Grandmother's
Lake, a sacred place of Mozyamskii Khanty. The name is connected
with the mistress of this place, Mosang Imi, or Grandmother, sister
of the goddes Kazym Imi (Dmitrieva 61).
On the Yugan River, Lake Larlumkina is considered to be sacred.
According to myth, warrior gods had a fight above this lake. When
the local god was wounded, he flew up into the sky, transformed
into thunder and became Chuv Iki. The reindeer drawing the sled
of this god dived into the water during the fight, and now they
are there, underneath the lake, two reindeer bulls. When the fishermen
set the nets, sometimes the nets are are stuck, and the fishermen
say that the nets are stuck on the antlers of these reindeer.
It is tabooed to cross this lake; one must make a circle along
the shore (Kurlumkin 1995). The belief that spirits of different
kinds live in these lakes in widespread. In the basins of rivers
Kazym, Vakh and Yugan there are sacred lakes where, according
to local beliefs, there live water spirits which look like very
big pike with horns.
The second subgroup of sacred water features are rivers of various
sizes examples of which are everywhere in the Khanty cultural
area. Yeming Yohan, Sacred river, which is situated above Kazym-sor,
opposite the mouth of the channel Dry Kazym, and according to
Kazym Khanty, people, both today and in the past, go there to
make shamanic rituals (Dmitrieva 73). In the Yugan basin, for
instance, there is the sacred place called Zolotaya Rechka or
Golden River, tributary of M. Yugan, known in Khanty as Ewt Yewt
Pisap (Kaimysov 1996). Passing this place for the first time in
a year, people throw money in the water. Women are prohibited
to go onto the shore there.
In the basin of Pim river is the sacred place, Var-Yaoun, which
is a tabooed river because local Khanty believe a malevolent god
lives there. It is prohibited to live on this river or even to
stop for a night while travelling there, otherwise something bad
will surely happen. When Khanty from other areas come there to
hunt, they hang an offering of material near the river. In the
Agan basin is a creek called Hlung Uri, which means Spirit Uri,
located near Lake Sys Lor. The toponymic legend connected with
this sacred place tells us that A Frog Goddess was going along
Agan. She saw that the river didn't flow; it was all dried. She
headed down the stream. Eventually these bad spirits, or they
might be good as well, barricaded or blocked the Agan. She learned
who did this, tore apart the barrier for good. It might have been
a fish weir. They probably had good fishing. She chased these
spirits all away. Some of them jumped into the lake yelling Sys,
sys, sys. The others who jumped into the uri yelled., Hlung It,
Sacred Uri. (V. Sopachina 1994)
Finally, we have placed swamps into this subgroup, although swamps
can also include some other nature elements. For instance, on
Kazym there are several sacred swamps among which is Von Kal,
which means Big Swamp. This is a sacred place for Mozyam Khanty
connected with the two main Mozyam Hlungs (Spirits), Great Hlung
and Lesser Hlung. They tell that each of them wears A a white
hat made of fur, white as snow, as ice. He doesn't take off this
hat all year (Dmitrieva 56).
The subgroup of smaller water features includes ponds, as well
as whirpools, rapids, turns and confluences of rivers. In the
upper part of M. Yugan River, above Achimovy, there is also a
whirlpool which is connected with mythological legends of Tondor
Iki, the main deity of this river. According to local beliefs,
one should throw two or three pieces of dried bread into this
whirlpool. "If one does not throw the dried bread, this god,
this Tondor Iki, won't like it and he might punish you" (Kolsomov
1996). Near this place on M. Yugan there is a bend in the river
named Tlor Voyak Hlung, where according to legend a warrior named
Loon was wounded. The place is considered to be sacred. The legend
says: "The gods were fighting among each other at this place
where the river makes a sharp turn. One of them dived to escape
his enemy, and appeared {further] only in the swamp to get air.
The second god [who also dived] sent ducks to the surface to breathe
for him" (Kolsomov 1996).
Landforms
The second major category of natural sacred places comprises landforms.
Most prominent here are high places which include hillocks, hills,
ridges, and very high hills. Another subgroup consists of promontories
and islands, a group including higher, dry places in swamps. A
third, smaller group consists of groves, mostly birch, small patches
of forest. A fourth group consists of individual sacred trees
of unusual shape or rare types and individual stones, also with
unusual size or shape.
High places in the Ob' Basin are relatively rare. This singularity
and the dominating character of such formations naturally predispose
the sacralization of these objects. Almost all the distinguished
high places have sacred status and accordingly ritual and mythological
significance. On the rivers Yugan, Trom-Agan and Pim, sacred high
places are most often called kot myx, meaning "earth house."
A kot myx is a god's house. On Trom-Agan, above the mouth of its
tributary, Ai-Trom-Agan, there is a sacred place for all Ob'Khanty,
a hill called Torom Yaoun Kot Myx. Offerings are brought here
regular at the beginning of seasonal activities and sporadically
for other reasons. On the top of this hill is a high, distinguished
pine tree on which Khanty hang pieces of fabric. Trom-Aganskii
Khanty say that the mountain with the pine tree is nothing else
than the house with the chimney pipe. There is a custom according
to which newly married Khanty come to this place to pray and make
offering at the beginning of their married life. Women are prohibited
to go on top. In this case, the husband climbs to the top to make
the offering and the new wife stays in the boat by the shore.
Also usually it is tabooed to remove something from a kot myx
(Sopochin 1995).
There is a whole group of memorates concerning people who violated
this taboo, for example, by breaking a branch of a tree on a kot
myx, with the result that the offender's arm withered or he died.
The owner of a kot myx could be not only one of the river patron
dieties, venerated by the whole community, but also a family spirit.
Thus on Kanterov family land in the Pim river basin there is sacred
Ochet Vut Mutikh Kot Myx. This is a Kanterov sacred place where
their family hlung (spirit) lives. Women of this family take wood
from this place for the images they make of their personal protecting
spirits (Kanterov 1996).
Kot Myx are a particularly threatened group of sacred sites. In
the lower part of B. Yugan, it is said, there was a sacred place
for all Ob' Khanty mentioned long ago by Dunin-Gorkavitch (II:
150), Yegutskaya [Evutskaya] Gora. Khanty from different places
came here to make offerings. In the Seventies this sacred mountain
was within a territory of oil development and almost leveled,
but there are still stories devoted to this mountain in local
oral tradition. On Trom Agan a high place dedicated to Yaoun Imi,
the Old Woman of the River, was destroyed entirely. Now only a
large hole in the ground exists where once a hill stood (Sopochin
1995). This is because these hills are made entirely of sand which
is dug up to provide the material for the raised roadbed constructed
throughout Western Siberia.
The second subgroup of sacred places includes such landforms as
islands and promontories. Kulemzin reports that Vas-Yugan Khanty
worship the promontory, Pyay Imi (Old Woman), located in the Lake
Tukh-Emtor, and brought her offerings there. The sacred legend
about the origins of this promontory is probably a fragment of
ancient cosmogonic myth: "One family, the head of which was
Old Woman, decided to go down Ob' and get to Vas-Yugan. They say
they never found Vas-Yugan, but they got on Nyurolka river, and
began to go up the river Tukh-Sigeh, which goes to Nyurolka and
stream out of Lake Tukh-Emtor. A famine began. There was a custom
there: if there was nothing to kill, one should bring a gift.
On one promontory on Tukh-Sigeh, an old woman sacrificed as a
gift one of her sons, killed him and left him in the forest under
a cedar. She gave him as a gift to the promontory." ( Kulemzin
and Lukina 1973: 24)
A third subgroup includes sacred groves and strips ( Russ., bory)
of forest. Some groves, for instance, birch groves, Kulemzin writes,
were worshipped like protectors of settlements, and the people
should follow a number of rules in such groves. In these groves
are special places which serve as protectors of individual families.
According to the reports of early ethnographers such as Castren
and Karjalainen, one could often see wooden images or faces of
protective spirits carved on trees. These images were destroyed
everywhere during the involuntary baptizing in the 18th century,
in the Thirties of the present century as part of the Soviet atheism
campaign, and also in the last two decades as part of the process
of oil development, when acts of vandalism take place. Sacred
bory can be found in the basin of r. Kazym. One such place is
situated on the lrft bank of river Kazym below the mouth of Xul-lorskaya
protoko, Sopir Neh Angkhim, which means Sopir the Ravine-Forest
Woman. This is a beautiful place with hills with an unmixed pine
forest on them. Here also is a sacred pine tree which only men
are permitted to come to. This yar (ravine-forest) is marked by
legend. According to local belief, a forest woman lives there.
Some say one leg of this woman is human, the other a moose leg;
in other variants, both legs are moose, or one is moose, one is
bear. This person is surrounded by a cycle of living oral tradition,
which includes not only narratives but songs performed by Khanty
during sacrifices. In one of these variants, it is said that the
forest woman met a hunter. She asked him to marry her, promised
hunting luck, proposed a whole box of clothes, but he refused.
Then she prophesied misfortune for him, and misfortune came (Dmitrieva
38).
Finally, individual trees and stones are also considered to be
sacred, "visible images of the spirit owners"( Kulemzin
Znakomtes 98). In the materials we have collected, most often
sacred trees are pines or larches. For instance, in the upper
part of M. Yugan, between the uppermost part of the river and
the tributary Kol Kuchin Yagun, near the swamp there is a tree
without branches and with a pine cone on its top. It is a sacred
pine tree, called Tondor Iki Vyaekh, which means "Stick of
the God Tondor Iki"(Kolsomov 1996) In Kazym region, there
are a number of examples of sacred trees that are worshipped.
On the left bank of the river Voch Pai Yuhan, there is a sacred
larch, with the carved image of the god Nyangk Vongkhip Iki [The
Old Man Carved on the Larch]. This tree is situated near the road,
and formerly, when they passed by this place with their reindeer,
they stopped and prayed: "This god helps us to shoot well
during the hunting" (Dmitrieva 66). Another example is Saxil
Yukh [Russ., talnik, var], near village Rezany, on the right bank
of the Ob', a large tree covered with moss, which looks as if
it is dressed in a winter fur parka. Nothing near this tree can
be touched. (Dmitreiva 76)
The stone cult is widespread throughout Siberia and the Far North
and considered to be one of the most ancient forms of religion.
A number of examples can be met in the region of the B. Yugan.
For example, on the upper part of M. Yugan, there is a sacred
stone in the water near the shore, the shape of which reminds
Khanty of the head of a bear. Near this stone there always stand
"skis with heels", that is, traditional Khanty skis
[pokh zhon imeyish]. This stone is oiled with fish grease as a
sacrifice to the spirit. They say that the head of Pupi [bear]
is above the water, and the spirit himself, dressed in the clothes
is under the water (Kolsomov 1996). Another sacred stone is situated
in the middle of M. Yugan River near Kinyamino. This is the spirit
Kon Pal Iki. The stone is very big, about a meter and a half long.
"If somebody doesn't know its there, he can hit it with the
motor or something else. When the water is low, it sticks out.
They throw coins into the water at this place" (Kolsomov
1996). Pimskii Khanty from Kanterov family told us that in the
uppermost parts of Pim and Kazym, there is a sacred stone having
the shape of a 4-cornered table. "Kazym Imi left it for Pimskii
and Trom-Aganskii people who can't come to her own place, so that
they could leave there fabric for her or cut a reindeer."
The sacred stone is called Kazym Imi Pesan (Kazym Imi's Table)
(Kanterov 1996)
Lastly, we should mention tabooed places. For instance, there
is a sacred complex on Kazym with the name, Piltyng Kal. In this
swamp there are "high hills, like chums, seven high hills,
where according to legend live seven deities called Piltyng Kal
Yokh, or Piltyng Kal Iket. They are worshipped by Amninskiye Khanty.
It is tabooed to go to this sacred place. Offerings and sacrifices
were made on the left bank of the Amni River in the forest. They
have made a labas for the deities and dressed the wooden images
there in white robes" (Dmitreiva 46). There is also data
that the upper part of r. Lamin is also a sacred place where people
could neither live nor hunt (V. Sopochina 1994). Khanty ethnographer,
Agrafena Sopochina (Pesikova 1995) thinks that the basic function
these tabooed territories was to provide a haven for the reproduction
of game animals. This is why from ancient times these territories
were considered taboo. Nobody could disturb animals or plants
there.
THE PROBLEMATICS OF CREATING TYPOLOGIES OF NATURAL SACRED
PLACES FOR REGIMES OF LEGAL PROTECTION
The preservation of sacred places is one of the keys to insuring
cultural survival. However, achieving this goal requires overcoming
not only the acknowledged variety of difficult sociopolitical
problems, but also some very important theoretical and methodological
ones. On the one hand, the development of national or international
regimes of legal protection requires generalized categories of
sites which can accomodate the dynamic character of tradition.
On the other, generalized categories have the potential for missing
the site-specific or culture-specific features of a place from
which its sacred character derives. One solution might be to generate
simple lists or registers of identified sacred places, but such
lists require some generalized principles to justify the inclusion
of places in the register. They also lack the ability to guide
planners in terms of what to take into account in the development
process, and tend to be generated by the development projects
that disclose the existence of sacred places at the last minute.
This tension between generalized (emic) typologies and culture-specific
(etic) typologies is especially felt in developing protection
regimes for natural sacred places of indigenous peoples. Our concerns
focus on three main areas of confusion.
Problems of Form
It is typical to identify natural sacred sites according to particular
elements of landscape. For the Khanty, these would include: lakes,
rivers, swamps, uris, whirlpools, rapids, turns and confluences
of rivers, hills, ravines, islands, promontories, sacred groves,
individual sacred trees and stones. Two difficulties emerge with
such a simple strategy: the problems of Complexity and Scale.
Complexity
Such a simple model of identification does not take into consideration
that natural sacred places may often be composed of several natural
elements. On the Yugan, Pim and Kazym rivers, for example, the
majority of sacred swamps include different kinds of high places:
hillocks (R., bugor,), ridges (R., gryady), "islands"
(R., ostrov), or isolated trees, although there are several examples
that indicate that simply swamps themselves can have special status.
Sometimes different toponyms point to the same place. Iming Soyem
(Sacred Creek) is located in the Trom-Agan basin near Jubilenie
village, is also called by local people call this place Svetoe
Ovrag, Sacred Ravine. The problem is even further complicated
when one considers that such natural sacred elements may also
include cultural elements, such as contructions to house the spirits.
The region of Lake Larlumkina on Yugan river is considered in
its combination of several natural and cultural elements: the
lake itself and high places near the lake shore, as well as a
three shrines, a cemetery and two archaeological sites. One very
knowledgeable Khant suggested that the entire basin of the Pim
River is considered by many to be sacred (Pesikova 1995).
Scale
The complexity of such forms raises the question of what exactly
should be protected in a site-based regime of legal protection.
This is a matter of both Area and Access. Area questions have
to do with establishing boundaries of sites to be protected; in
very large areas, like Larlumkina, this may involve developing
zonation strategies. Access questions are raised by the scale
of a site as well as its function: Does access require a special
route to the site that should be incorporated into a protection
plan? Do the functions need to be protected from observers?
Problems of Function
We found it very difficult to strictly categorize sites according
to their presumed function. When a place is referred to as sacred,
what attributes of it are actually being pointed out. Our experience
with the Siberian Khanty, as well as with American Indians (see
Kelley and Francis 1994), suggests that a place is typically referred
to as sacred because of its association with religious belief
(myth) and/or cultic practice. Yet even these terms acquire a
certain flexibility as tradition begins to shape itself out of
the seeds of an origin long since lost to cultural memory.
Cultic Functions
Because of the high visibility of and anthropology's bias towards
cultic activity, sites associated with offerings, sacrifices or
other forms of cultic behavior are often foregrounded in typological
systems, in a manner parallel to the foregrounding of sites marked
by constructions as opposed to sacred natural features. This poses
several problems, not the least of which is the fact that the
sacredness of cultic sites may be reconfigured. Cultic practices
may persist even after any memory of the mythic event or association
which focused attention on the place has been lost. We have contemporary
data that the religious power that once energized recently destroyed
sacred places can be communicated to newly revealed sacred places,
or, simply, new sacred places, hitherto unknown, may be revealed
to the community through dreaming or other culturally-sanctioned
channels (Kantirov 1996). These places have no mythic associations.
Mnemonic-Iconic Function
As American anthropologist Keith Basso has demonstrated, the association
of place with myth and legend often gives sites a substantive
mnemonic function as a culture's beliefs, values and normative
practices are mapped onto a landscape filled with stories. For
example, on B. Yugan, below Talakhova village near Kykalova, there
is a sacred whirlpool which is marked by the following legend.
"When people came and began to travel along the Yugan, and
the [god's] wife was probably very ill-natured. She began to confuse
people in order to delay them. Later, the grassy bank there, when
it dried entirely [after the water lowered later in summer] became
like stone. Her husband became angry and kicked her. Below this
place appeared a deep, deep whirlpool. 'If you don't want to look
at people, then you should live in a deep whirlpool,' [so the
husband addressed the wife]"(Kurlumkin 1996). It is important
to understand that even if no cultic practice emerges from this
association, the association is functional in the strictest sense.
Nevertheless, there is as much flexibility with this mnemonic-iconic
function as with the cultic function. Religious belief can be
enlarged from a mythic association to include associations with
legend. An archaeological site, Vosh Vort Pai, on the upper M.
Yugan is considered sacred because of its legendary, quasi-mythic
associations: To this place sand had been brought to create an
island in the middle of the swamp on which a fortress had been
built of large, palisaded logs. Other logs were dragged up the
slope and stacked for defense; when the enemy attacked, the logs
were released to roll down upon them. According to legend, people
known as Arex Yakh, The People Sung About, lived there: "The
people were about three meters tall. What was strange about them
was that they had no navels. These warrior giants'names were Nyomyl
and Toruk" (Kaimysov 1996). Interestingly, other texts we
recorded from different sources (Kanterov 1996) say that the gods
had no navels.
While many countries have a regime of legal protection for cultic
places categorized as places of religious worship as well as a
regime of legal protection for places with a mnemonic-iconic function
categorized as places of cultural significance, it is unclear
whether the legal systems of most countries comprehend the ambiguity
in and linkage between these categories from an indigenous perspective.
The result is a scattershot pattern of protection that focuses
on some sites highly-marked by Western standards, while overlooking
the broad and complex network of functionality that links these
more visible sites with the other, less-visible ones
Problems of Participation
The complex relationship between social structure and indigenous
religious belief and practice is also a cause for confusion. We
have identified over 150 sacred sites in the Middle Ob' region,
but the fractions of the population who participate, through knowledge,
belief or practice, in the traditions associated with these sites
varies considerable and poses problems not only for developing
both typologies and regimes of legal protection.
Khanty social organization is based on extended families or lineages,
with related lineages grouped into clans (Khanty: cir ). While
the present settlement pattern has been influenced by migration
and forced relocation within the Middle Ob' region, evidence from
our own fieldwork and the ethnographic record indicates that different
Khanty clans even today claim traditional use rights to different
river systems tributary to the Ob=, in part because they believe
their lineage was founded by divine ancestors who were also responsible
for the creation of the river systems on which the majority of
the clan lives (Pupi [bear] cir: B. Yugan River; makh [beaver]
cir: Malyi Yugan River). Most Khanty extended families live on
traditional family hunting territories, protected by family gods
who are considered offspring of the lineage's founding deities.
These lineage deities are the seven sons of the high god, each
a patron of a major tributary of the Ob' Roughly speaking, the
principal deities are responsible for cosmological-level events,
their first generation offspring for the watersheds of the major
tributaries, and the second generation offspring for individual
family lands along each watershed. Traditional Khanty thus believe
that sacred power has been historically invested in both the landscape
and the lineage.
This, however, creates a apparent problematic hierarchy of interest.
Khanty do distinguish between obsche (community) sites, clan sites
and family sites. Nevertheless, because each category is embedded
in the one above it, all, even a particular extended family's
sacred place, have a bearing on the success and prosperity of
the Khanty. Consequently, it would be incorrect to view community-wide
sites as somehow more significant than the sacred places of individual,
extended families.
CONCLUSION
Just as Khanty oral tradition shapes the concept of the surrounding
landscape, so the same tradition models the Khanty concept about
themselves. Our work demonstrates how two basic resources of ethnocultural
semiotics, language and land, are used by a people for establishing
the norms of social behavior and moral values reinforcing these
norms. To ignore this complex relationship means to deprive a
people of their cultural niche, their surrounding world constructed
in their own perspectives of time and space. Protecting the cultural
landscape that forms the basis for national self-consciousness
for an indigenous people will be immensely difficult, and for
many, like the Khanty, time is quickly running out.
REFERENCES
Publications
Balalaeva, O.(forthcoming 1999) Opyt tipologii svyashennykh
mestvostochnykhkhantov. [Working Typology of the Sacred Places
of the Eastern Khanty.] Forthcoming in Wiget, A. .et al. Ocherkii
istorii tradtsionnogo zemlpolzovaniya Khantov [ Essays on Khanty
Traditional Land Use]. Yekaterinburg:Tezis Publishing.
Balzer, M. M. (1994) "Khanty" in: Encyclopedia of World Cultures, ed. Paul Friedrich. New Haven: Yale (Human Relations Area Files).
Basso, Keith. (1996) Wisdom Sits in Places: Landscape and Language among the Western Apache. Albuquerque: U of New Mexico P.
Bugrov, V. I. et. al., (1994) Drevnii Gorod Na Obi: Istoria Surguta [Ancient City on the Ob': A History of Surgut]. Yekaterinburg: Printing House "Thesis".
Cherepanova, G. P. and O. E. Morozov. (1994) Ugorskoe Naslednie: Ugrian Heritage. Yekaterinburg: History and Archaeology Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Urals Branch.
Dunin-Gorkavich, A. A. (1904: Rpt. Moscow: Libereya, 1995). Tobolskii Sever: Obshii obzorstrany, yeya yestestvennykh bogatstv i promyshlennoi deyatelnosti naseleniya. [ The Tobolsk North: A General Survey of the Country, Its Natural Wealth, and Industrial Activity of the Population.] 3 vols.
Golovnev, A. V. (1995) Govoryaschie Kultury: Traditsii Samodiitsev I Ugrov [Talking Cultures: Samoyed and Ugrian Traditions]. Yekaterinburg: Urals Branch, Russian Academy of Science.
Gondatti, N. L. (1888) Sledy Yazychestva u Inorodtsev Severo-Zapadnoi Sibiri [Traces of Paganism among the Non-Christians of North-Western Siberia] Moscow: Tipografia E. G. Potopova.
Karjalainen, K. F. (Porvoo, 1922; Rpt.:Tomsk. Tomsk U P, 1995) Religiya Yugorskikh Narodov [Trans. N. V. Lukina, Die Religion der Jugra-Volker].
Kelley, Klara and Harris Francis. (1994) Navajo Sacred Places. Bloomington: Indiana U.
Kulemzin, V. M. (1984) Chelovek i Priroda v Verovaniyakh Khantov [Man and Nature in Khanty Belief]. Tomsk: Tomsk University Press.
Kulemzin, V. M. and N. V. Lukina. (1973) Legendy i Skazki Khantov [Khanty Legends and Tales]. Tomsk: Tomsk University Press.
______.(1992) Znakomtyes: Khanty. [Introducing Khanty]. Novosibirsk: Nauka.
Levin, M. G. and Potapov, L. P. (1956 ;Rpt. And Trans., Chicago: University of Chicago,.1964). The Peoples of Siberia.
Wiget, A. et al. (forthcoming 1999) Ocherkii istorii tradtsionnogo zemlpolzovaniya Khantov [ Essays on Khanty Traditional Land Use]. Yekaterinburg: Tezis Publishing.
Wiget, A. and O. Balalaeva. (Winter 1997a) Black Snow: Oil and the Khanty of West Siberia, Cultural Survival Quarterly 20: 13-15.
_____. (1997b)ASaving Siberia's Khanty from Oil Development: Proposed Biosphere Reserve Would Protect a Threatened Culture. Surviving Together 46 (Spring ):22-2
_____. (1997c) ANational Communities, Native Land Tenure and Self-Determination Among the Eastern Khanty. Polar Geography. 21. 1: 10-33.
Fieldwork Interviews
Dmitrieva, Tatiana. Archives of Unpublished Fieldnotes on Kazym
Toponymy. Urals State University, Yekaterinburg.
Kaimysov, V. D. Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Ugut District, Surgut Region, July 1996.
Kanterov, K. Y., Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Sortim District, Surgut Region, July 1995, July 1996.
Kolsomov, E. Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Ugut District, Surgut Region, July 1995, July 1996.
Kurlumkin, P. V., Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Ugut District, Surgut Region, July 1996.
Pesikova, Agrafena. Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Russkinskiye District, Surgut Region, June 1995.
Sopochin, J. Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Russkinskiye District, Surgut Region, June 1995.
Sopochina, V. Authors' Fieldwork Interviews. Russkinskiye District, Surgut Region, June 1994.